If the concern is data privacy, then pass comprehensive data privacy legislation that applies to every company — banning one app is just political theater that solves nothing and normalizes government control of the internet.
0
Should governments ban TikTok to protect national security, or does that set a dangerous precedent?
50% PRO
50% CON
Pro 5
Con 5
It genuinely breaks my heart that a generation of young creators, activists, and artists could lose their entire community and livelihood because politicians who can't figure out their iPad decided an app is scary.
0
The 'national security' framing is doing a lot of heavy lifting here — show me the concrete evidence of harm, because vague fears about China watching teenagers dance aren't a constitutional justification for banning an entire platform.
0
I've been on TikTok for four years and built an actual small business off it, and nobody has ever stolen my data in any way that Facebook and Google haven't been doing for decades without a single ban proposed.
0
Once you let governments decide which apps are 'too dangerous,' you've handed them a censorship toolkit they will absolutely abuse — today it's TikTok, tomorrow it's whatever platform criticizes the wrong politician.
0
I work in cybersecurity and the sheer volume of data TikTok collects relative to its actual product needs is a massive red flag — there is no legitimate business reason for it, and governments banning it isn't censorship, it's basic threat management.
China banned Google, Facebook, and Twitter years ago, so spare me the hand-wringing about precedent — we're just finally playing by the same rules they set.
Every other social platform we've ever banned or restricted was for domestic reasons like antitrust — banning a foreign state-linked app is genuinely a different category and the slippery slope argument just doesn't hold up.
My kid spent three months in a TikTok rabbit hole that pushed increasingly dark content, and ByteDance answers to the Chinese Communist Party — I really don't care about the precedent argument when kids' heads are being filled with whatever Beijing wants.
The app literally harvests keystroke data, location history, and clipboard contents — at some point "precedent" is just a fancy word for doing nothing while a foreign adversary maps our infrastructure.