Minimum wage literally means the minimum — if you need an exception to go below the floor, you're just arguing that some workers deserve less protection than others, and I genuinely don't understand how that's legal.
0
Should employers be allowed to pay tipped workers below minimum wage?
50% PRO
50% CON
Pro 5
Con 5
My mom cleaned hotel rooms for years and never saw a tip in her life — the tipped carve-out mostly protects a specific kind of employer from paying fair wages while everyone acts like it's some proud tradition.
0
It's wild that we've built a system where a worker's basic income depends on whether a stranger is having a good day or not, that's not a labor market, that's a lottery.
0
Seven states have eliminated the tipped minimum wage and their restaurant industries didn't collapse — so the whole 'we can't afford it' argument from employers is basically just vibes at this point.
0
I waited tables for six years and there were absolutely nights where I made less than minimum wage after a slow Tuesday dinner shift — the 'tips will cover it' logic is just a way for restaurant owners to offload their payroll onto customers.
0
Small restaurants already operate on razor-thin margins, like 3-5% profit. Force them to double their labor costs overnight and you're not helping workers, you're just accelerating closures and automation.
The whole point of tips is that they reward good service — if you mandate full base wages regardless, you're basically telling servers their effort doesn't matter. That's bad for customers and frankly bad for workers who actually show up and work hard.
My wife is a server and she would RIOT if you took away her tips and gave her flat minimum wage. She clears way more than that on a good Friday night and she likes the hustle of earning it.
In states that eliminated the tip credit, multiple studies showed servers actually ended up earning less overall because customers tipped less when they knew the wage was already covered. Sometimes the 'obvious fix' makes things worse.
I bartended for 15 years and never once went home with less than $25/hour after tips. The current system works fine — killing the tip credit would just mean restaurants raise prices and cut staff to compensate.