Seven states have already eliminated the tipped minimum wage and restaurants there didn't collapse — they adjusted. The 'we can't afford it' argument from the industry is just not backed up by what actually happened.
0
Should employers be allowed to pay tipped workers below minimum wage?
50% PRO
50% CON
Pro 5
Con 5
Tipped workers also face way more harassment because they literally can't afford to stand up for themselves — they depend on keeping every customer happy just to survive. Subminimum wage doesn't just hurt wallets, it creates unsafe workplaces.
0
It's wild that we've somehow normalized workers legally being paid $2.13 an hour in some states. That's not a wage, that's a joke, and we just collectively agreed to let it happen.
0
The whole 'tips will make up the difference' argument falls apart immediately when you look at the data — tipped workers have poverty rates nearly double that of non-tipped workers. The system is broken by design.
0
I waited tables for six years and there were absolutely weeks where tips were slow and I couldn't cover rent. Your paycheck shouldn't depend on whether a customer is having a good day.
0
Eliminating the tip credit sounds compassionate but it's actually killed off tons of full-service restaurants in places that banned it — sometimes protecting a system means leaving it alone.
States already require employers to make up the difference if tips don't cover minimum wage, so the floor is still there — the tipped credit is just a smarter way to let the market reward good service.
My daughter bartends and she'd be furious if you took away her tips to give her a flat hourly — she clears $40/hr on a good weekend, that's not something you just legislate away.
The tipped wage model literally subsidizes restaurant prices for everyone. Force employers to pay full minimum wage and watch your $14 burger become a $20 burger real fast.
I waitressed for six years and honestly made way more than minimum wage most nights — the current system isn't broken, and fixing it would just mean owners cut hours to cover the extra labor costs.